Piriformis Syndrome: An Overlooked Cause of Buttock and Leg Pain

Not every case of buttock and leg pain is caused by a herniated disc. In my practice I frequently see patients who have been followed for months with a diagnosis of “herniated disc” but whose complaints have never resolved. In a considerable number of these patients the real problem is not in the lower back but in the piriformis muscle, which lies deep in the buttock.

The sciatic nerve runs beneath, and sometimes through, the piriformis muscle and can become compressed when this muscle is in chronic spasm or inflamed. This clinical picture, known in the literature as piriformis syndrome, closely mimics the course of a herniated disc and is therefore often missed. In this article I explain in plain language what piriformis syndrome is, what complaints it causes, why it is confused with a herniated disc, and the current treatment approaches.

Contents

  • What is piriformis syndrome?
  • The sciatic nerve and the piriformis muscle
  • Symptoms of piriformis syndrome
  • Why is it confused with a herniated disc?
  • Who is more commonly affected?
  • How is it diagnosed?
  • Treatment options and injection
  • Frequently asked questions

What Is Piriformis Syndrome?

Piriformis syndrome is a nerve entrapment condition (entrapment neuropathy) that occurs when the piriformis muscle, located deep behind the hip joint, compresses or irritates the sciatic nerve. The piriformis is a flat muscle that runs from the sacrum to the upper outer part of the thigh bone (greater trochanter) and helps rotate the hip outward.

When this muscle develops spasm, tightness, irritation after trauma or thickening (hypertrophy), the sciatic nerve right next to it comes under mechanical pressure. The result is pain, numbness and tingling that start in the buttock and spread down the back of the leg. Piriformis syndrome is not very common; the literature attributes it to a relatively small proportion of lower back and buttock pain. Even so, because its symptoms mimic well-known conditions, the diagnosis is often missed.

Because there is no single imaging test that confirms piriformis syndrome, it is considered a “diagnosis of exclusion”. In other words, conditions that cause similar complaints – such as a herniated disc, spinal stenosis and hip joint problems – are evaluated first, and piriformis syndrome comes to the fore once these have been ruled out.

The Relationship Between the Sciatic Nerve and the Piriformis Muscle

The sciatic nerve is the thickest and longest peripheral nerve in the body. It leaves the lower part of the spine, passes through the buttock, runs down the back of the thigh and continues to the foot. Along this route it lies very close to the piriformis muscle.

Several anatomical variations in the course of the sciatic nerve relative to the piriformis muscle have been described:

  • Most common arrangement: The whole sciatic nerve passes beneath the piriformis muscle. This is the case in the large majority of people.
  • Less common variations: Part of the nerve may pass through the muscle, and part beneath or above it.
  • Rare variation: An anatomy in which the entire sciatic nerve passes directly through the muscle is seen in a small proportion of people.

In people whose nerve passes through or very close to the muscle, contraction of the muscle presses on the nerve more easily. This explains why some individuals are more prone to piriformis syndrome.

What Are the Symptoms of Piriformis Syndrome?

Complaints are usually one-sided, but can rarely affect both sides. The most typical symptoms are:

  • Deep buttock pain: A dull or throbbing pain felt deep in the seat area, usually on one side.
  • Pain radiating down the leg (sciatica): The pain spreads from the back of the thigh to the calf and sometimes to the foot.
  • Numbness and tingling: Changes in sensation along the path of the sciatic nerve.
  • Pain that worsens with sitting: Sitting for long periods, driving or sitting on a hard surface in particular make the pain noticeably worse.
  • Triggered by movement: Climbing stairs, walking long distances or turning the hip inward can aggravate the pain.

A typical “clue”

Pain that starts deep in the buttock and worsens with sitting and inward rotation of the hip – rather than with movements of the lower back – should bring piriformis syndrome to mind.

Warning signs

Progressive muscle weakness, changes in bladder or bowel control, or spreading numbness may indicate a different condition that needs urgent assessment; in that case, see a doctor without delay.

Why Is It Confused With a Herniated Disc?

What a herniated disc and piriformis syndrome have in common is that both affect the sciatic nerve. Both cause pain radiating down the leg, numbness and tingling, so the two conditions look very similar clinically.

The key difference is the level at which the problem arises:

Feature Sciatica from a herniated disc Piriformis syndrome
Level of compression In the lower back, at the nerve roots leaving the spine In the buttock, at the level of the piriformis muscle
Lumbar MRI / X-ray A herniation is usually seen Often normal
Where the pain starts Lower back Deep in the buttock
Provoking examination finding Lower back movements, straight leg raise Tenderness along the piriformis, FAIR test

Because of this similarity, some patients are treated for a herniated disc for years, and some even undergo disc surgery, yet their complaints do not improve as expected – because the real problem lies in the piriformis muscle, which has never been addressed. That is why a careful physical examination is so important when pain radiates down the leg.

Who Is More Commonly Affected?

Certain lifestyles and occupational habits place constant strain on the piriformis muscle and set the stage for this condition:

  • People who sit for long periods: Desk and office workers.
  • Professional drivers: Drivers and long-distance travellers.
  • Athletes: Especially runners, cyclists and athletes who make repetitive hip movements.
  • Sudden strain: After a fall, a blow to the buttock or a sudden twisting movement.
  • Poor sitting habits: Habits such as carrying a wallet in the back pocket put continuous pressure on the muscle.

Clinical observations suggest that piriformis syndrome may be more common in women than in men.

How Is Piriformis Syndrome Diagnosed?

There is no single test that confirms piriformis syndrome. The diagnosis is based on a detailed history and, above all, the physical examination; imaging is used to rule out similar conditions.

Physical examination and provocative tests

During the examination, tenderness is sought along the line of the piriformis from the sacrum to the greater trochanter. Tests that stretch the muscle and provoke the sciatic nerve are then used to see whether the complaints are reproduced:

  • FAIR test: The piriformis is stretched by flexing, adducting and internally rotating the hip; reproduction of the pain is significant.
  • Pace test: Pain on abducting the hip against resistance in the sitting position.
  • Freiberg test: Buttock pain provoked by forced internal rotation of the extended thigh.
  • Beatty test: Buttock pain when lifting the affected leg while lying on the unaffected side.

None of these tests is 100% conclusive on its own, so evaluating several findings together increases the reliability of the diagnosis.

Imaging and further tests

Lumbar MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) and X-rays are requested to rule out conditions such as a herniated disc or spinal stenosis. EMG (nerve conduction studies) can help distinguish similar neurological conditions. In recent years, ultrasound has become a valuable tool for assessing the piriformis muscle in real time and, in particular, for placing injections accurately.

Treatment of Piriformis Syndrome

The aim of treatment is to relieve the muscle spasm and reduce the mechanical pressure on the sciatic nerve. The approach is step by step; most patients improve without the need for surgery.

1. Conservative treatment (first step)

  • Temporarily reducing activities that trigger the complaints, and rest.
  • Stretching and strengthening exercises for the piriformis muscle.
  • Physical therapy and manual techniques.
  • Medication to reduce pain and inflammation, under a doctor’s supervision.

With appropriate conservative treatment, many patients notice clear improvement, usually within 4–8 weeks. An ergonomic sitting arrangement and regular stretching help prevent recurrence.

2. Piriformis muscle injection (in resistant cases)

In cases that do not respond to conservative treatment, the piriformis muscle injections we perform aim to relieve the spasm in the muscle and reduce the mechanical pressure on the sciatic nerve. The injection is usually given directly into the piriformis muscle under ultrasound guidance, using a local anaesthetic combined with cortisone when needed.

This method has a dual value: it treats the pain and, if the complaints subside after the injection, it also supports the diagnosis. In selected patients with resistant, long-standing muscle spasm, botulinum toxin (Botox) injections may also be an option.

3. Surgery (in rare cases)

Surgery is considered only in very selected cases that are long-standing, resistant and have not improved despite all other methods. The aim is to relieve the pressure on the sciatic nerve completely.

There is no one-size-fits-all treatment plan. Whether exercise or injection is more suitable is decided individually, based on the duration and severity of the pain, the examination findings and the patient’s general condition.

Prevention and Everyday Tips

  • Avoid sitting in the same position for long periods; get up and move for a few minutes every 30–45 minutes.
  • Do hip and piriformis stretching exercises regularly.
  • Make your sitting arrangement ergonomic; avoid carrying a wallet in your back pocket.
  • Warm up before sport and cool down afterwards.
  • Avoid sudden, forceful twisting and bending movements.

If your complaints persist, the right diagnosis saves time

If pain that spreads to your buttock and leg and worsens with sitting has not settled for weeks, a detailed examination can clarify whether the source is in the lower back or in the piriformis muscle. You can book an appointment for an evaluation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is piriformis syndrome distinguished from a herniated disc?

Both cause sciatica-like pain radiating down the leg, but in piriformis syndrome the source of the pain is the muscle deep in the buttock. In these patients lumbar MRI and X-rays are often normal; tenderness along the piriformis on examination and positive tests such as the FAIR test help make the distinction.

Does piriformis syndrome go away on its own?

Mild cases usually improve markedly within 4–8 weeks with rest, stretching exercises and appropriate physical therapy. However, if chronic spasm has set in, the complaints may not resolve on their own and additional treatment such as an injection may be needed.

How is a piriformis injection done, and is it painful?

The injection is usually given directly into the piriformis muscle under ultrasound guidance, using a local anaesthetic combined with cortisone when needed. When performed under imaging guidance the procedure is precise and short; most patients describe a tolerable discomfort.

Which movements should I avoid with piriformis syndrome?

Sitting still for long periods, sitting cross-legged on a hard surface, sudden twisting and bending movements, and carrying a wallet in the back pocket can worsen the complaints. Avoiding these triggers and taking regular breaks to stand up is recommended.

Does piriformis syndrome require surgery?

No. The great majority of cases are managed with conservative treatment and injections. Surgery is considered only in selected cases that are long-standing, resistant and have not responded to any other method.

Related articles: Facet joint–related low back pain · Low back pain

Disclaimer: This content is for general information only and does not replace a medical examination. Diagnosis and treatment are individual. If you have complaints, please consult a doctor.

Prof. Dr. Akif Albayrak — Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgeon, Spine Surgeon

Author’s publications on this topic

Selected scientific studies by our team on this subject:

  1. Albayrak A, Ozcafer R, Balioglu MB, Kargin D, Atici Y, Ermis MN. Piriformis syndrome: treatment of a rare cause of posterior hip pain with fluoroscopic-guided injection. Hip Int. 2015;25(2):172-5. doi:10.5301/hipint.5000219